The Man Who Simulated Nature

Berni Alder and the Birth of Molecular Dynamics

The visionary physicist who established computer simulation as the third pillar of science

Molecular Dynamics

Computer Simulation

Statistical Mechanics

The Third Pillar of Science

In the mid-20th century, as scientists were unraveling the secrets of the atom, a quiet revolution was brewing that would transform how we study nature.

For centuries, science had advanced through two complementary approaches: theory and experiment. Then came Berni Julian Alder, a visionary physicist who helped establish a third pathway to discovery: computer simulation 1 6 .

His work, begun on clunky mechanical calculators and early electronic computers, ultimately gave scientists a powerful new microscope—one that could peer into the hidden dance of atoms and molecules. For making atomistic computational simulation a new pathway to unexpected discoveries, parallel with traditional theory and experiment, Alder was awarded the National Medal of Science by President Obama in 2008 1 6 .

The Three Pillars of Modern Science

From War Refugee to Scientific Pioneer

1925

Born to Jewish parents in Duisburg, Germany 1 4 .

1933

Fled with his family to Zurich, Switzerland as the Nazis came to power 1 4 .

1941

Undertook a perilous journey to the United States 4 6 .

World War II

Served as a radar technician in the U.S. Navy 1 2 .

Post-War

Earned degrees in chemistry at UC Berkeley 1 2 .

PhD

Studied at Caltech under John Gamble Kirkwood, exploring computer applications in statistical mechanics 1 2 .

Early Research Setback

Alder and computer scientist Stan Frankel developed an early Monte Carlo algorithm to calculate the properties of hard-sphere fluids, but their publication was delayed, leading to their work being scooped by Nicholas Metropolis and his group at Los Alamos 2 8 .

This early setback didn't deter Alder—it fueled his determination to develop even more powerful computational techniques.

The Simulation Revolution: From Billiard Balls to Molecules

In 1955, Alder joined the newly established Lawrence Radiation Laboratory (now Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory), where he found an environment ripe for innovation 1 2 . The laboratory was well-funded as part of the cold war effort and had embraced advanced computing from its founding days 2 .

Strategic Choice: Hard Spheres

Alder focused initially on a seemingly simple system: a collection of hard spheres, like microscopic billiard balls 2 3 . He chose this system strategically—since the dynamics of colliding spheres could be exactly determined, it silenced critics who argued that simulation results might be artifacts of inaccurate computer arithmetic 2 .

Molecular Dynamics Method

The molecular dynamics technique modeled a sequence of collisions in a system of spheres and tracked how the system evolved over time 2 . Unlike Monte Carlo methods, which could only address equilibrium properties, molecular dynamics could simulate how systems changed over time 6 .

Key Developments in Early Molecular Dynamics

Time Period Key Development Significance
Early 1950s Early Monte Carlo algorithms Random sampling for equilibrium properties
Mid-1950s Molecular Dynamics method Could study dynamics and time-dependent changes
1957 Liquid-solid phase transition discovery Showed hard spheres could form crystals
1970 Long-time tail discovery Revealed unexpected slow relaxation in fluids
1980 Quantum Monte Carlo methods Extended simulation to quantum systems

The Hard Sphere Breakthrough: A Revolution in Phase Transitions

One of the most significant controversies Alder tackled with his new simulation method was the nature of phase transitions—how materials change from liquid to solid and back. Textbook wisdom held that solids form because of attractive interactions between molecules: the regular arrangement of atoms in a crystal lattice minimizes their energy 2 .

The Research Question

Alder and Wainwright set out to test whether a system of hard spheres with only repulsive interactions—no attractive forces at all—could undergo a phase transition 1 2 .

Simulation Procedure
1
System Setup

They modeled hundreds of hard spheres confined in a box, representing atoms in a material 5 .

2
Compression Simulation

The system was progressively compressed, increasing the density of spheres 2 3 .

3
Collision Tracking

The computer calculated the trajectories and collisions of spheres over time 2 .

4
Observation

At sufficiently high density, the spheres spontaneously arranged themselves into an ordered, crystalline structure 2 3 .

Hard Sphere Phase Transition
Liquid Phase Low Density
Transition Point Critical Density
Solid Phase High Density
Counterintuitive Finding

The regular arrangement of spheres in a crystal actually allows more space for movement than the disordered liquid state—a counterintuitive finding that overturned conventional wisdom 2 .

A Legacy of Connection and Mentorship

Those who worked with Alder remember not just his scientific brilliance but his unique approach to collaboration. He conducted discussions in a friendly manner while thoughtfully questioning assumptions and conclusions 1 . Whether one was a beginning graduate student or a senior scientist, Alder engaged with them equally, leaving them with a deepened understanding of physics 1 .

"Although working for Berni was often intense and difficult, I did have fun."

Mary Ann Mansigh Karlsen, who worked as a programmer with Alder for 25 years 5

Even in his later years, Alder maintained his curiosity and work ethic. In a 2009 interview at age 84, he noted, "My working habits are 'never before lunch…'. I go to work in the afternoons. Three days a week, I'm at Livermore, and two days a week at UC Berkeley" 6 . He continued to mentor students and pursue new challenges in hydrodynamics and quantum mechanics almost until his death in 2020 at age 95 4 6 .

Alder's Impact
Molecular Dynamics

Foundation for modern computational chemistry and materials science

Hard Sphere Model

Revolutionized understanding of phase transitions

Quantum Simulations

Enabled development of density functional theory

Scientific Mentorship

Inspired generations of computational scientists

Unexpected Discoveries

In 1970, while studying the microscopic origins of hydrodynamic behavior, he and Wainwright discovered that velocity autocorrelations in fluids decay much more slowly than expected 1 5 . Instead of the exponential decay predicted by conventional theory, they found an algebraic decay—now known as the "long-time tail" 1 5 .

Quantum Extensions

In the late 1970s, Alder again broke new ground by extending simulation techniques to quantum systems 1 7 . With David Ceperley, he developed methods to study the behavior of electrons, leading to their definitive 1980 calculation of the electron gas model 1 .

Conclusion: The Simulation Scientist

Berni Alder's career spanned more than 65 years and transformed how science is done across multiple disciplines 1 .

From his early work on hard spheres to quantum simulations, he demonstrated that computer simulation could be more than just number-crunching—it could be a powerful instrument of discovery, capable of revealing phenomena inaccessible to both theory and experiment 2 .

"When you for the first time know something which nobody else knows, which is important to medicine or whatever field you're working on, I mean there's no higher reward in this world and no higher high that you can get than working in science and achieving a goal that's been waiting there for a long time" 3 .

His legacy lives on every time a researcher uses molecular dynamics to design new materials, understand protein folding, or explore the fundamental behavior of matter. The CECAM prize, named in his honor, recognizes exceptional contributions to the simulation of microscopic properties of matter 1 5 .

References